Ideology versus economics

Solving our information crisis requires more than one solution because there is more than one problem

Michael Slaby

--

This article is part of a series of thinking examining modern media and our civic life including my new book For ALL the People out now.

Originally published on 7 Bridges

Margaret Sullivan — the brilliant and thoughtful media columnist for The Washington Post — wrote last weekend about how to start undermining Fox News by pressuring their biggest advertisers. Nicholas Kristof picked up the baton this week saying, “the problem with Fox isn’t that it’s conservative but that it monetizes conspiracy theories and disinformation in ways that are sometimes lethal.” Both pieces are worth the full read, but ultimately beg a really essential question: if Fox News is ideologically motivated, will economic pressure be sufficient to change it?

They have unquestionably benefited from the fact that their ideological goals have well-aligned with the ideological sorting and promotion of extremism inherent in our modern media systems such that their profitability aligns with their ideological goals. Undermining them by going after their revenue by shaming advertisers is clearly an opportunity to apply meaningful pressure. However, will it actually change their ideological editorial behavior? Or will they simply turn toward philanthropic subsidy (a la The Mercers and Breitbart or Bezos and The Washington Post) rather than thriving in a damaged and counterproductive (in civic terms) attention economy?

Yes, we should demand that brands face accountability for hypocritical stances. And yes, Fox News should face the declining revenue that will result from brands acknowledging that they cannot support the active undermining of democracy with their left hand while promoting civic participation with their right. But reclaiming our fourth estate is going to require more than economic incentives to ensure that we get the kind of high-quality information we need to be effective citizens. We need to revisit the underlying principles of journalism that were largely codified in the 1920s by the Columbia Journalism School. We need to revisit media ownership regulation along with broader view of antitrust enforcement. We need to revisit our…

--

--

Michael Slaby

Media, technology, politics, and saving the world in various combinations — Chief Strategist at Harmony Labs— author of For ALL the People bit.ly/fatp-a